The Effectiveness of Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment as Part of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment in Tanzania
Abstract
It is generally accepted that for any country to develop socio-economically, there must be various types of investment. It should also be understood that the planning and implementation of such investment projects generate negative and positive impact to mother environment. Once the environment, both natural and cultural, is impacted upon, it affects people including other living things in return both in the short- and long-run. Because of this fact, under normal circumstances, development projects impact the environment. Therefore, environmental experts conduct systematic examination to determine whether or not such projects would have adverse impact on the environment in its totality to include the physical, biological, cultural and socio-economical aspects. To double-check the effectiveness of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment, a few scholars have assessed its efficiency. Unfortunately, such assessment on developmental projects has virtually excluded the evaluation of the efficacy of Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment as part of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment. The exclusion is inappropriate because cultural heritage resources are part of the environment, and the planning and implementation of developmental projects similarly affect cultural heritage resources. This article examines the effectiveness of Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment as part of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment particularly on the qualifications of those who do it, the frequency of Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment inclusion in Environmental and Social Impact Assessment, and whether or not Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment mitigation measures are implemented. The results indicate that unregistered experts never carry out Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment, Environmental and Social Impact Assessment reports Studies in the African Past - Vol. 13/14 21 do not reach cultural heritage authorities for review, and in most cases, the prepared Environmental and Social Impact Assessment statements do not include Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment impact mitigation measures and when included they are not implemented by developers. In this regard, we argue that the situation is a result of weak legislation to make Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment a mandatory exercise, absence of will by both government and environmental agencies dealing with ESIA, and negligence of developers and Environmental and Social Impact Assessment experts. Subsequently, this study recommends measures to be taken to make Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment a useful part of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment €“ to make it rescue and manage cultural heritage from threats resulting from developmental projects.
Key words: Iron smithing, blooms, Southern Waterberg, Rooiberg, metallography
References
References
Ali, O. M. (2010). The role of EIA studies in the management and conservation
in Sudan. In H. Kiriama, I. Odiaua, & A. Sinamai (eds.). Cultural heritage
impact assessment in Africa: An overview (pp. 44-50). Mombasa: CHDA.
Arazi, N. (2009). Cultural research management in Africa: challenges, dangers
and opportunities. Azania: Archaeological Research in Africa, 44(1), 95-
Arazi, N. (2011). Safeguarding archaeological resources in Africa; Policies,
methods, and issues of non-compliance. The African Archaeological
Review, 28(1), 7-38.
Bigambo, R. (2013). Towards Proper Management of Cultural Heritage Assets in
Saadan. University of Dar es Salaam, Dar es Salaam: Unpublished MA.
Thesis.
Bond, A., Langstaff, L., & Ruelle, C. (2002). Monitoring and post evaluation of
the cultural heritage component of environmental assessment. SUITPosition Paper (4).
Boyle, J. (1998). Cultural influence on implementing environmental impact
assessment: Insight from Thailand, Indonesia, and Malaysia.
Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 18(2), 95-116.
Braithwaite, R., Hopkins, D., & Grover, W. (2001). Archaeological and other
materials and cultural assets. In P. Morris, & R. Therivel, Methods of
environmental impact assessment (2nd ed.). London: Spon Press.
Bushozi, P. M. (2014). Towards Sustainable Cultural Heritage Management
in Tanzania: A Case Study of Kalenga and Mlambalas sites in Iringa,
Southern Tanzania. South African Archaeological Bulletin, 69(200), 136-
Campbell, I. (2000). Environmental impact assessment, cultural heritage and
dams in Eastern Africa. Working Paper, World Commission on Dams.
Studies in the African Past - Vol. 13/14
Chami, M. F., & Lyaya, E. C. (2015). Assessment of Tourist Satisfaction in Cultural
Heritage Tourism Destinations in Tanzania: The Case of Zanzibar Stone
Town Tourism. Studies in the African Past, 12, 261-273.
Chirikure, S. (2013). Heritage conservation in Africa: The good, the bad and
the challenges. Journal of Heritage Conservation in Africa, 109(1/2), 1-3.
Coles, S. (2007). Practitioner perspective on the barriers and constraints to
the assessment of socio-economic impacts in ESIA. University of East
Anglia: Unpublished MA. Dissertation.
Dale, P., Chapman, P., & McDonald, M. L. (1997). Social impact assessment in
Queensland: Why practice lags behind legislative opportunity. Impact
Assessment, 159-179.
Eboreime, J. (2008). Challenges of Heritage Management in Africa. In W.
Ndoro, A. Mumma, & G. Abungu, Cultural Heritage and Law Protecting
Immovable Heritage in Sub-Saharan Africa (pp. 1-5). Rome: ICCROM.
Edward, E. (2005). An investigation into the quality of coverage of cultural
heritage impacts in UK environmental impact assessment. Masters
Dissertation. Norwich: University of Anglia. EMA (2004). The
Environmental Management Act, 2004.
Fleming, A. (2011). Promoting a constructive relationship between heritage and
development. Heritage Conservation Conference: Conserving Heritage
and Development; partners or rivals? Hong Kong.
Glasson, J. Therivel, R. & Chadwick, A. (2005). Introduction to Environmental
Impact Assessment, Third Edition. London: UCL Press.
Hall, A. (2009). Initiating a Review of National Heritage Legislation in the South
African Experience. In W. Ndoro, & G. Pwiti, Legal Framework for the
Protection of Immovable Cultural Heritage in Africa (pp. 36-41). ROME:
ICCROM.
Studies in the African Past - Vol. 13/14 43
Ichumbaki, E. B. (2012). The State of Cultural Significance and Management
of Built Heritage Assets of Lindi and Mtwara Regions, Tanzania. MA
(Archaeology) Dissertation. Dar es Salaam: Unpublished, University of
Dar es Salaam.
Jerpasen, G. B., & Larsen, K. C. (2011). Visual impact of wind farms on cultural
heritage: A Norwegian case study. Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, 31, 206-215.
Jones, C. (2010). Cultural Heritage in Environmental Impact Assessment:
Reflection from England and Northwest Europe. In T. Bloomers, H.
Kars, A.V. Valk, & M. Wisnen, The Cultural Landscape and Heritage
Paradox: Protection and Development of the Dutch Archaeological,
Historical Landscape and Its European Dimension, pp. 445-459. Hague,
Netherlands: Amsterdam University Press.
Jones, C., & Slinn, P. (2008). Cultural heritage in EIA. Reflections on practice
in North-West Europe. Journal of Environmental Assessment and
Management, 10(3), 215-238.
Kamamba, D. (2009). Cultural heritage legislation in Tanzania. In W. Ndoro,
& G. Pwiti. Legal framework for the protection of immovable cultural
heritage in Africa (pp. 13-17). ROME: ICCROM.
King, T. (2011). Cultural Heritage, Environmental Impact Assessment, and
People. the proceedings of the World Archaeological Congress Intercongress
on Heritage Management in Asia. Beijing: Published 2013 by the Chinese
Academy of Social Sciences [CASS].
Lambrick, G., Hind, J., Hey, G., & Spandl, K. (2005). Planarch 2: Review of
Cultural Heritage Coverage in Environmental Impact Assessments.
Oxford: Oxford Archaeology.
Langstaff, L., & Bond, A. (2002). The Consideration of Cultural Heritage within
EIA Practice Throughout Europe. Suit Position Paper, 2/6.
Studies in the African Past - Vol. 13/14
Lazzarotto, A. (2009). Effectiveness of environmental impact assessment in
Santa Catarina-Brazil: A case of tourism. MA Dissertation, University
of East Anglia.
Lindblom, I. (2012). Quality of cultural heritage in EIA, twenty years of
experience in Norway. Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, 51-57.
Lwoga, N. B., Anderson, W., Mapunda, B. B., & Mossberg, T. D. (2015). SocialPsychological Influences for Stakeholders Engagement in Conservation
of Built Heritage Attractions in Tanzania. ATLAS Africa Conference, (pp.
-15).
Lwoga, N. B., & Mabulla, A. Z. (2013). Institutional and Legislative Conflicts
in Management of Built Heritage in Neoliberal Cities: A Case of Dar es
Salaam City. The Journal of African Archaeology Network, 89-112.
Mabulla, A. Z. (1996). Tanzania ' s Endangered Heritage: A Call for a Protection
Program. African Archaeological Review, 13(3, 199), 197-214.
Mabulla, A. Z., & Bower, J. (2010). Cultural Heritage Management n Tanzania ' s
Protected Areas; Challenges and Future Prospects. The Journal of
Heritage Stewardship, 7(1).
Mapunda, B. B. (1999). Destruction of Archaeological Heritage in Tanzania:
The Cost of Ignorance. In N. Brodie, & P. Watson, Illicit Antiquities:
Destruction of the World ' s Archaeological Heritage. London: Cambridge.
