Trade Reforms and Total Factor Productivity
Abstract
The relationship between trade reforms and industry performance has been undecided both on theoretical and empirical grounds. Amidst of this, Ethiopia has undertaken series of trade and other economic reform measures since 1992. The objective of this paper is to assess firm-level TFP heterogeneity in the Ethiopian manufacturing industry during and post-trade reform periods. Based on unbalanced panel data of 8395 manufacturing firms engaging 10 and above persons for the period (1996 and 2007), TFP was estimated using Olley and Pakes (1996) with Yasar et al. (2008) STATA application. The study found heterogeneous firm-level TFP in line with contemporary economic theories with skewed distribution with relatively high concentration of unproductive firms to the left. Import-intensive, exporting, incumbent and also smaller and large-scale firms performed more productively as compared to resource-based, nonexporting, exiting and medium sized firms, respectively, over the entire period. While the manufacturing sector has become more productive during the post-reform period, private, non-exporting, import-dependent, large-scale and incumbent firms contributed a statically significant improvement in TFP scores during this period. These results are consistent with many present-day studies. Despite being based on local-resources, exporting firms have not shown TFP improvement mainly because of the scarcity of raw materials. Overall, the findings suggest that the government may need to investigate the bottlenecks holding back the linkage between agro-processing industries and the agricultural sector to improve the performance of resource-based industries in general, and the exporting firms in particular. Medium scale industries also require an equal support as small enterprises, in terms of access to market, loans and other services so as to cope-up with the competitive push. Otherwise, further trade reform would improve the overall TFP of the manufacturing sector if the necessary precaution is put in place in terms of addressing the above and related bottlenecks.
References
Higher Productivity Evidence from Slovenia. Journal of International Economics, 73: 69 €“98.
Deramiyagala, S. & B. Fine. 2001. New Trade Theory versus Old Trade Theory: A Continuing Enigma. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 25(6): 809 €“826.
Dijkstra, A. G. 2000. Trade Liberalization and Industrial Development in Latin America. World Development, 28(9): 1567 €“1582.
Eaton, J. & S. Kortum. 1996. Trade in Ideas: Productivity and Patenting in the OECD. Journal International Economics. 40; 251 €“278.
Epifani, P. 2003. Trade Liberalization, Firm Performance, and Labor Market Outcomes in the Developing World: What Can We Ackerberg, D., C. Benkard, S. Berry & A. Pakes. 2006.
Econometric Tools for Analyzing Market Outcomes ' , Prepared for the Handbook of Econometrics, In J. Heckman & E. Learner (eds.). 2007. Amsterdam: North-Hold
Agénor, R. & P. Montiel. 2008. Macroeconomics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Aghion, P., S. Redding, R. Burgess & F. Zilibotti. 2005. Entry Liberalization and Inequality in Industrial Performance. Journal of the European Economic Association, 3(2 €“3): 291 €“302.
Altenburg, T. 2010. Industrial Policy in Ethiopia. Discussion Paper 2/2010. Bonn. German Development Institute.
Amiti, M. & J. Konings. 2007. Trade Liberalization, Intermediate Inputs and Productivity: Evidence from Indonesia. American Economic Review, 97(5): 1611 €“38.
Arellano, M. & S. Bond. 1991. Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo
Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations. Review of Economic Studies, 58: 277 €“297.
Arnold, J.M. & K. Hussinger. 2005. Export Behaviour and Firm Productivity in German Manufacturing: A Firm-Level Analysis. Review of World Economics, 141(2): 219 €“243.
Aw, B., Y., C. Xiaomin & M. J. Roberts. 2001. Firm-level Evidence on Productivity Differentials and Turnover in Taiwanese Manufacturing. Journal of Development Economics, 66(1): 51 €“86.
Baltagi, B.H. 2005. Econometric Analysis of Panel Data. Third Edition, West Sussex: John Wiley. & Sons, Ltd.
Baltagi, B.H & P.X. Wu. 1999. Unequally Spaced Panel Data Regression with AR (1) Disturbances. Econometric Theory 15, 814 €“823.
Bernard, A.B. & J.B. Jensen. 1999. Exceptional Exporter Performance: Cause, Effect, or Both? Journal of International Economics, 46(1): 1 €“25.
Bernard, A.B., S. Redding & P.K. Schott. 2007. Comparative Advantage and Heterogeneous Firms. Review of Economic Studies 74: 31 €“66.
Bigsten, A., P. Collier, S. Dercon, M. Fafchmps, B. Gautheir, J.W. Gunning, A. Oduro, R. Oostendrorp, C. Patillo, M. Sóderbom, F. Teal & A. Zeufck. 2002. Do African Manufacturing Firms Learn from Exporting. CSAE WPS/2002 €“09.
Blundell, R. & S. Bond. 1998. Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions in Dynamic Panel-Data Models. Journal of Econometrics, 87: 115 €“143.
€”. 2000. GMM Estimation with Persistent Panel Data: An Application to Production Functions. Econometric Reviews. 19, 321 €“340.
Central Statistical Agency (CSA). 1998. Report on Large and Medium Scale Manufacturing and Electricity Industries Survey. Addis Ababa.
€”. 2005. Report on Large and Medium Scale Manufacturing and Electricity Industries Survey. Addis Ababa.
€”. 2007. Report on Large and Medium Scale Manufacturing and Electricity Industries Survey. Addis Ababa.
€”. 2008. Report on Large and Medium-Scale Manufacturing and Electricity Industries Survey. Addis Ababa.
Costantini, J. & M. Melitz. 2007. The Dynamics of Firm-Level Adjustment to Trade Liberalization. Available from <http://scholar.harvard.edu/melitz/publications>. 1/10/2015.
Damijan, P. J., M, Knell, B. Majcen & M. Rojec. 2003. The Role of FDI, R&D Accumulation and Trade in Transferring Technology to Transition Countries: Evidence from Firm Panel Data for Eight Transition Countries. Economic Systems, 27: 189 €“204.
Damijan, J.P., J. Sousa & O. Lamotte. 2009. Does international Openness Affect the Productivity of Local Firms? Evidence from South-Eastern Europe. Economics of Transition, 17(3): 559 €“586.
De Loecker, J. 2007. Do Exporters Generate Learn from Micro-Level Data?. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3063. Available from https://openknowledge. worldbank.org> (1.9/2015).
Ericson, R. & A. Pakes. 1995. Markov-Perfect Industry Dynamics: A Framework for Empirical Work. Review of Economic Studies 62: 53-82.
FarnÅ„as, J.C. & A.M. Marcos. 2007. Exporting and Economic Performance Firm-level Evidence of Spanish Manufacturing. The World Economy, pp. 618 €“646.
Fernandes, A. 2007. Trade Policy, Trade Volumes and Plant Level Productivity in Colombian Manufacturing Industries. Journal of International Economics, 71(1): 52 €“71.
Worku Gebeyehu Alemayehu
Gebreeyesus, M. 2006. Essays on Firm Turnover, Growth and Investment Behaviour in Ethiopian Manufacturing. PhD Dissertation, Göteborg University.
Girma, S., D. Greenaway & R. Kneller. 2004. Does Exporting Increase Productivity? A Microeconometric Analysis of Matched Firms. Review of International Economics, 12(5): 855 €“866.
Green, W. H. 2012. Econometric Analysis. Boston: Pearson Education, Inc.
Greenaway, D., R.C. Hine & P.W. Wright. 1999. An Empirical Assessment of the Impact of Trade on Employment in the United Kingdom. European Journal of Political Economy, (15): 485 €“500.
Greenaway, D. & Z. Yu. 2004. Firm-Level Interactions between Exporting and Productivity: Industry-Specific Evidence. Review of World Economics, 140(3): 376 €“392.
Gross, G. & E. Helpman. 1991. Trade, Innovation and Growth. The American Economic Review, 80(2): 86 €“91.
Haddad, M. 1993. How Trade Liberalization Affected Productivity in Morocco. World Bank, Policy Research Papers, 1096.
Haddad, M. & A. Harrison. 1993. Are there Positive Spillovers from Direct Foreign Investment? Evidence from a Panel Data for Morocco. Journal of Development Economics, 42(1): 51 €“74.
Harrison, A. 1994. Productivity, Imperfect Competition and Trade Reform: Theory and Evidence. Journal of International Economics 36: 53 €“73.
Harris, R. & Q. Li. 2008. Evaluating the Contribution of Exporting UK Productivity Growth: Some Microeconomic Evidence. The World Economy, 31(2): 212 €“235.
Hessen, H. 2008. Export Diversification and Economic Growth. Commission on Growth and Development. Working Paper 21.
Hock, I. 1962. Estimation of Production Parameters Combining Time-Series and CrossSection Data. Econometrica, 30(1): 34 €“53.
Holmes, T.J. & J.A. Schmitz Jr.. 2001. A Gain from Unproductive to Productive Entrepreneurship. Journal of Monetary Economics, 47: 417 €“ 446.
Hopenhayn, H. 1992. Entry, Exit and Firm Dynamics in Long-Run Equilibrium. Econometrica, 60:1127 €“1150.
Hwang, A.R. 2003. Exports, Returns to Scale, and Total Factor Productivity: The Case of Taiwanese Manufacturing Industries. Review of Development Economics, 7(2): 204 €“216.
Kasahara, H. & J. Rodrigue. 2008. Does the use of Imported Intermediates Increase Productivity? Plant-level Evidence. Journal of Development Economics 87, 106 €“118.
Kim, S. & G. Han. 2001. A Decomposition of Total Factor Productivity Growth in Korean Manufacturing Industries: a Stochastic Frontier Approach. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 16:269 €“81.
Kim, S. & M. Shafi ' i. 2009. Factor Determinants of Total Factor Productivity Growth in Malaysian Manufacturing Industries: A Decomposition Analysis. Asian Pacific Economic Literature, 23(1): 48 €“65.
Klette, T.J. & Z. Griliches. 1996. The Inconsistency of Common Scale Estimators when Output Prices are Unobservable and Endogenous. Journal of Applied Econometrics 11(4): 343 €“361.
Konings, J. 2000. The Effects of Direct Foreign Investment on Domestic Firms: Evidence from Firm-level Panel Data in Emerging Economies. William Davidson Institute. Working Paper 344.
Konings, J. & H. Vandenbussche. 2008. Heterogeneous Responses of Firms to Trade Protection. Journal of International Economics, 76: 371 €“383
.
Lee, J. 1995. Capital Goods Imports and Long run Growth. Journal of Development Economics, 48(1): 91 €“110.
Levinsohn, J. & A. Petrin. 2003. Estimating Production Functions Using Inputs to Control for Unobservables. Review of Economic Studies, 70: 317 €“341.
Lileeva, A. 2008. Trade Liberalization and Productivity Dynamics: Evidence from Canada. Canadian Journal of Economics, 41(2): 360 €“390.
Mairesse, J & J. Jaumandreu. 2005. Panel-data Estimates of the Production Function and the Revenue Function: What Difference Does It Make? Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 107(4): 651 €“672.
Marschak, J. & W.H. Andrews. 1944. Random Simultaneous Equations and the Theory of Production. Econometica, 12(3 €“4): 143 €“205.
Melitz, M.J. 2003. The Impact of Trade on Intra-Industry Reallocations and Aggregate Industry Productivity. Econometrica, 71(6): 1695 €“1725.
Melitz, M.J. & G.P. Ottaviano. 2008. Market Size, Trade, and Productivity. Review of Economic Studies Limited, 75: 295 €“316.
Mengistae, T. & C. Pattillo. 2002. Export Orientation and Productivity in Sub-Saharan Africa, IMF Working Paper 02/89.
Mengistae, T. & F. Teal. 1998. Trade Liberalisation, Regional Integration and Firm Performance in Africa ' s Manufacturing Sector. A Report to the European Commission, REP98-1.
Muendeler, M.A. 2004. Trade, Technology and Productivity: A Study of Brazilian Manufacturers. CESifo Working Paper 1148.
Mundlak, Y. 1961. Empirical Production Function Free of Management Bias. Journal of Farm Economics, 43(1): 44 €“56.
National Bank of Belgium. 2008. Exports and Productivity- A Comparable Evidence for 14 Countries ' , Brussels. Working Paper 128.
Navaretti, G.B., R. Faini & B. Gauthier. 2006. The Impact of Trade Liberalization on Enterprises in Small Backward Economies: the Case of Chad and Gabon. Review of Development Economies, 10(3): 452 €“465.
Nelson, R. 1981. Research on Productivity Growth and Productivity Differences: Dead Ends and New Departures. Journal of Economic Literature. 19: 1029 €“64.
Okten, C. & K.P. Arin. 2006. The Effects of Privatization on Efficiency: How Does Privatization Work? World Development, 34(9): 1537 €“1556.
Olley, G. S & A. Pakes. 1996. The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunication Equipment Industry. Econometrica, 64(6): 1263 €“1297. 56 Worku Gebeyehu Alemayehu
Pavcnik, N. 2002. Trade Liberalization, Exit, and Productivity Improvements: Evidence from Chilean Plants. Review of Economic Studies, 69: 245 €“276
Schwab, K. (ed.). 2012. The Global Competitiveness Report. 2012 €“2013. Geneva: World Economic Forum.
Shiferaw, A. 2005. Firm Heterogeneity and Market Selection in Sub-Saharan Africa: Does it Spur Industrial Progress. ISS, The Hague. Working Paper Series 414.
Sinha, R. 1993. Foreign Participation and Technical Efficiency in Indian Industry. Journal of Applied Economics, 25: 583 €“88.
Slaughter, M. 2004. Infant-Industry Protection and Trade
Liberalization in Developing Countries. Research Report by Nathan Associates Inc. Arlington, Virginia to USAID/ Washington.
StataCorp. 2009. Stata: Release 11. Statistical Software. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP
.
€”. 2011. Stata: Release 12. Statistical Software. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP.
€”. 2013. Stata: Release 13. Statistical Software. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP. Available from <http://www.stata.com/manuals13> (1/8/2015).
Taymaz, E. & K. Yilmaz. 2007. Productivity and Trade Orientation: Turkish Manufacturing Industry Before and After the Custom Union. The Journal of International Trade and Diplomacy, 1(1): 127 €“154.
Tybout, J.R. 2000. Manufacturing Firms in Developing Countries: How Well Do They Do, and Why? Journal of Economic Literature, 38: 11 €“44.
Tybout, J. & M. Westbrook. 1995. Trade Liberalization and Dimensions of Efficiency
Change in Mexican Manufacturing Industries. Journal of International Economics, 39(1 €“2): 53 €“78.
Valodia, I. & M. Velia. 2006. Macro-Micro Linkages in Trade: Trade, Efficiency and Competitiveness of Manufacturing Firms in Durban, South Africa. Journal of African Economics, 15(4): 688 €“721.
Van Biesebroeck, J. 2005. Exporting Raises Productivity in Sub-Saharan African Manufacturing Firms. Journal of International Economics, 67: 373 €“391
Windmeijer, F. 2005. A Finite Sample Correction for the Variance of Linear Efficient TwoStep GMM Estimators. Journal of Econometrics, 126: 25 €“51.
Yasar, M., C.H. Nelson & R. Rejesus. 2006. Productivity and Exporting Status of Manufacturing Firms: Evidence from Quintile Regressions. Review of World Economics, 142(4): 675 €“694.
Yasar, M., R. Raciborski & B. Poi. 2008. Production Function Estimation in Stata Using the Olley and Pakes Method. Stata Journal, 8(2): 221 €“231.
Yeaple, S. 2005. A, Simple Model of Firm Heterogeneity, International Trade and Wages. Journal of International Economics, 65: 1 €“20.
Zerihun, A. 2008. Industrialization Policy and Industrial Development Strategy in Ethiopia. In T. Assefa, (ed.). Digest of Ethiopia ' s National Policies, Strategies and Programs. Addis Ababa: Forum for Social Studies, 239 €“281.
